StratNavApp.com banner ad
Showing posts with label business models. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business models. Show all posts

Book review of Subscribed: Why the Subscription Model Will Be Your Company's Future - and What to Do About It

Cover of the book Subscribed

We don't have to look too far to see the impact that subscription-based business models are having on everyday life.

We no longer buy music - we listen to it on subscription from Spotify. We no longer buy films, we watch them on subscription from Netflix.

In the subscription economy, we no longer pay a lump sum upfront to own or use something forever. Instead, we pay a monthly or annual fee for the right to access that benefit for that period of time. As soon as we stop paying, we lose access to that benefit.

Even capital intensive purchases like cars are being impacted by this change. Instead of buying a car outright, more of us are entering into Personal Contract Plans (PCPs) or other similar arrangements. With these, we pay a monthly charge for the right to use a vehicle. Of course, under a PCP we have the right to buy the vehicle at a predetermined price at the end of the deal. But the dealer's hope is that you trade it in for a new car on a new PCP arrangement and keep paying.

I do most of my consulting in the financial services industry. This has always run on something like a subscription basis. When you open a bank account, you pay for it either through explicit charges or reduced interest rates until you close it. When you take out insurance, you pay a monthly or annual premium. When you invest or take out a pension, you pay a monthly 'usage-based' fee based on the value of your assets.

So, I am quite familiar with many of the challenges that subscription-based business models bring. Providers' expenses are highest at the start of the relationship. And then they hope that the customers will stay long enough to become profitable. As a result, providers spend a lot of time worrying about:

  • How to reduce the costs of acquisition. These include sales and marketing, distribution and onboarding) 
  • How to reduce the churn rate. This is the percentage of customers who leave during any defined period.

In their book, Subscribed, Tien Tzuo and Gabe Weisert take a broader view of the trend towards subscription-based business models and their impacts.

The subscription economy is customer-centric

The book sets the scene with some bold claims. For example, it claims that "companies running subscription models grow their revenue more than nine times fast than the S&P 500". In fact, there is a whole addendum of juicy numbers describing the rapid growth of subscription-based companies. It draws most of these from the usage statistics of a "comprehensive billing and finance platform for subscription-based businesses", called Zuora. Disclosure: Tien Tzuo is the CEO of Zuora.

One of the reasons for the success of subscription-based businesses is that each and every subscriber has a unique identifier. All of the data company collects about them is mapped to this unique identifier. I am a little tempted to point out that they may be conflating two separate issues. Those being: customer-centric data management and a subscription-based revenue model.

The authors point to companies like Amazon, Google, Facebook, Apple and Netflix as evidence of their hypothesis. However, Amazon was a runaway success long before it introduced it's Amazon Prime subscription model. It succeeded on the basis that it exploited customer-centric data using unique customer identifiers right from the start.

Amazon, Google, Facebook, Apple and Netflix are all examples of digitally native customer-centric businesses. They also happen to be (increasingly) subscription-based.

The authors contrast this against 'traditional' businesses that mass produce and distribute physical goods. Such businesses tend to rely on Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. These are designed around physical goods - raw materials and finished products. They do a great job of managing operational efficiency, raw materials, inventory, purchase orders, sales, shipping and payroll. But they do a lousy job of managing customer relationships and experiences.

The book does not discuss Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems. It is fair to say that CRM systems have gone a long way towards addressing this. However, they are largely still bolt-ons to the underlying ERP-style systems. The result is a far cry from systems built around the customer and customer experience from the ground up.

Instead, what it does describe is how companies:

"...set up customer service departments! When in doubt, build another vertical silo—they launched market services, technical support lines, warranty contracts, and maintenance groups. The customer had truly arrived—they had their own department now. And that department was located way down at the far end of the supply chain, just past the loading dock."

The authors argue that the battle between Amazon and Walmart is not between online versus traditional retail. It is between customer-orientated data-driven app-centric flexible and omnichannel retail on the one hand and product-orientated retail on the other. (tweet this)

They conclude that:

"If you're still selling your product off shelves to strangers in five years, there's a good chance you're not going to make it to ten." (tweet this)

Changing consumer preferences

The book then goes on to talk about consumers changing preferences:

  • for services rather than products,
  • for outcomes rather than ownership, and
  • for constant improvement rather than planned obsolescence.

The authors describe how customers now "want the ride, not the car; the milk, not the cow." (I think this description is slightly misplaced. Buying milk still represents the old manufacturing to sale model, rather than the move to a subscription-based model.)

This broad societal change is nicely summed up in the final chapter:

Once upon a time, we used to know the people we bought from—the butcher, the baker, the blacksmith, the farmer. We used to know the people we sold to, the neighbors in our village. All that knowledge got lost a long time ago, when the Industrial Revolution ushered in the product era. But it’s coming back in a big way.

This trend is fueled and reinforced by a growing awareness of the environmental consequences of mass consumption over the last century.

An added advantage of doing so is that companies can learn by watching how their customers use their products and services. In the traditional product model, once the customer received the product, the manufacturer typically has little, if any idea, of how the customer used it or even if they used it at all.

With a subscription service, providers can gather data on an ongoing basis. They can analyse that data in realtime. And they can use that analysis to continually improve the product or service. Existing customers can benefit from those improvements immediately. Often they don't even need to pay for a new version or upgrade.

Even where businesses stick with a traditional product-based model, there is an increasing drive to package these with value-added services. For example, Fender now sells a subscription-based online video service called Fender Play. This teaches customers how to play their guitars. It also creates an additional revenue stream. More than that, it creates a more intimate relationship between the company and its customers. And it reduced the rate at which customers give up trying to learn to play.

Apparently, International Data Corporate predicts that by 2020, 50% of the world's largest enterprises will see the majority of their business depend on the ability to create digitally-enhanced products, services and experiences.

Market research needs no longer to rely on what focus groups and survey respondents say they want but can draw real-time data generated by what real customers actually do. (See also: Everybody Lies, the evolution of market research.)

The new economics

The authors argue that traditional businesses rely on advertising to sell individual products to strangers. Subscription businesses, on the other hand, rely on customer relationships to continue to provide services and upsell new services to loyal customers.

They devote a number of pages in the book to describing a challenge that traditional businesses face when making this switch. They call this challenge "eating the fish" (for reasons which escape me). By way of example, they describe a software business moving from selling on-premise software installations to SaaS solutions in the cloud. The economics change from a large purchase and installation revenue followed by upgrade every few years to a smaller, recurring monthly fee. The difficulty in this is that revenues actually decrease in the first few years after making the change.

The long-term advantage, however, is that instead of starting each year with zero sales on the books, subscription businesses start each year with a stable recurring revenue stream.

"You're talking about shifting from an asset transfer model to a long-term relationship."

The authors contrast the two models. The old imperative is to:

  • sell more units,
  • increase the price of those units, or
  • decrease the cost required to make them.
The new model is driven by the imperatives to:

  • acquire more customers,
  • increase the value of those customers and
  • hold on to them longer.

(I think they miss the opportunity to serve those customers at a lower cost, but their point is well made.)

Crucially, this requires a shift from a sales mentality - make the sale and move on - to a service mentality - win the customer and then stay as close to them as you can.

More subtly, current accounting practices do not distinguish between historic sales and recurring revenues. The traditional manufacturing and sales model is very transaction and backwards-looking. The subscription model is more relational and forward-looking.

As an aside, I would note that the insurance industry has been grappling with this for years. Insurance accounting allows for the recognition of anticipated revenues in the form of 'embedded value'.

However, this change in thinking could be a double-edged sword. I half suspect that it is part of what allows so many startups to burn through so much cash acquiring new customers in the hope that they will stay long enough to become profitable. Sadly, as we've seen, if this does not come to pass, the investors may be left with little to show for it.

Churn rates

The addendum also included some annual churn rates. If I am honest, these came as a bit of a surprise to me. These were:

  1. B2B: 27%
  2. B2C: 30%
  3. B2A: 26%
  4. Corporate Services: 37%
  5. Telecommunications: 26%
  6. SaaS: 24%
  7. Media: 33% 

For all the benefits of the subscription economy, these seemed high. I was left wondering if customers who simply buy products might not stick with them for longer, on average, than that. Or perhaps, as we move towards this new business model, we're discovering just how poor many companies are at keeping their customers satisfied.

Conclusions

Subscribed is packed with analysis and examples of industries and companies grappling with this fundamental and far-reaching change in business model.

I would highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in business models. If you're still in any doubt, I will leave you with the authors' conclusion that a subscription business is...

"...also a much happier business. Why? Because subscriptions are the only business model that is entirely based on the happiness of your customers."

Of Operating Models, Business Models and Strategy

I was talking earlier this week about the operating model changes that would be required to deliver a particular strategy, and someone (quite rightly) challenged me to be more clear on what I meant by operating model, and how it relates to other ideas like business model.

Andrew Campbell is as good an authority on the subject as any. He teaches Business Models on the Ashridge Executive Education course and is also the author of the book Operating Model Canvas (which I would highly recommend).

Handily he has also written a short and accessible article on Business Models and Operating Models.

In it, he confirms the conventional summary of an Operating Model as People, Processes and Technology. (He goes on to define an alternative which may be technically better but somehow seems less accessible.)

He refers also to Alex Osterwalder's book Business Model Canvas, which I would also highly recommend.

I think you could probably summarise:
  • Operating Model: How you operate.
  • Business Model: What you offer to Who and how you make money from it.
  • Strategy: Why this achieves your purpose.

See also:

How to use a Business Model Canvas

I first came across the Business Model Canvas in the book "Business Model Generation" by Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur.

It is a simple template for describing the various key elements that make up a business model - that is, how a firm extracts value from the markets in which it competes.

The Business Model Canvas is used to describe the following 9 elements of a business model:

KP = Key Partners

Which key partners does the firm rely on, and for what? They could be normal supply, outsource or distribution relationships, but could also include strategic alliances between non-competitors or competitors, and joint ventures. Relationships may be exclusive and tightly contracted or more open market. It is also important to be clear what the firm gains from the partnership that it could not get alone, and therefore how partners are selected and managed.

KA = Key Activities

What key activities must the company perform in order to deliver its value propositions through its channels to its customers? These could include all the activities in the value chain, from product development to manufacturing to sales and marketing and post-sales support, as well as supporting processes such as hiring and developing staff, knowledge management and problem solving, and developing systems. See also How to use Porter's Value Chain Analysis.

KR = Key Resources

What key resources does the organisation need to deliver its value propositions? Key resources can include people and skills, physical assets, intellectual property, patents and copyrights, as well as data, brands and financial resources.

VP = Value Proposition

What value does the company offer its customers? Value propositions describe which of the customers' problems are solved using the bundle of products and services a company offers, or which of the customers' needs are satisfied. A competitive value proposition is typically something which is new in the market, or which performs better, is more flexible/customisable, is better designed or is cheaper than what is already available in the market.

CR = Customer Relationships

What kinds of relationships will the company have with its customers? Customer relationships can offer high levels of personal service, or expect customers to self-serve. Business can be transactional where the customer relationship is limited to the purchase process, or relational, where the customer enters into a longer term relationship with the business. Customer relationships can span the pre-sales, sales and post-sales activities, like servicing, cross-sales and up-selling.

CH = Channels

Through which channels will the company deliver its products or services to its customer? This should cover the entire customer process including initial awareness, pre-sales, sales and post-sales experiences. This should include channel mix, multi- and mono-channel strategies as well as channel access and ownership.

CS = Customer Segments

What customer segments will the business serve, and equally importantly, which segments will it not actively pursue? Customer segments are distinct customer categories which can be described in terms of what they need from the product or service and how they will use it, how many of them there are, where they can be found and through which channels they can be reached, what kinds of relationships you will have with them, what price they are willing to pay, and, taking all of the above into account, how profitable they are likely to be. See also What is segmentation and how does it work?

C$ = Cost Structure

What is the cost structure of the business? Costs may be fixed or variable, one-off or recurring, sunk or capitalised, deferred (as liabilities) or contingent (as reserves). Businesses with higher variable costs (relative to fixed costs) typically require less upfront investment and scale more easily, whilst businesses with higher fixed costs typically benefit more from scale. A low-cost business model will require a different cost structure to a high value-add business model.

R$ = Revenue Structure

How much are customers really willing to pay? Revenues can be in the form of a one-off purchase price, or recurring subscriptions, usage or rental income. Pricing can be fixed, variable, or differential. Discounting can be used to encourage specific buyer behaviours.

The Business Model Canvas is typically laid out in the following format:

The layout of the Business Model Canvas

Business models can be work-shopped by outlining the above template on a large whiteboard, or using brown paper, and then writing short descriptions of each of the business model elements on post-it notes pasted in the appropriate blocks.

The business model canvas can be used to describe and validate a startup, an existing business model or to design one or more future business models or business model changes.

There are two things that are important in the design of a business model. Firstly, it must obviously be both viable and profitable. But secondly, it must be internally consistent. That is, the cost structure must be consistent with the economics of the key partnership arrangements, the cost of performing the key activities, and the acquisition and retention or maintenance of the key resources. These, in turn, must be capable of delivering the value proposition through the customer channels and relationships to the selected customer segments to the extent that they are willing to pay the price built into the revenue structure. In my opinion, it is the assessment of this internal consistency where the Business Model Canvas adds the most value.

The Business Model Canvas is now available in StratNavApp.com, the collaborative online tool for strategy development and execution. The image below shows what a Business Model Canvas (for Airbnb) might look like in edit-mode in the tool (click to enlarge):

An example of a Business Model Canvas


See also:

What is your ecommerce business worth?

Ecommerce business models remain a fascination of mine - see my previous post and paper on eCommerce Business Models. They represent both a very visible forefront of innovation, as well as a rich graveyard of hubris triumphing over good strategy. And that is why I am featuring an infographic from Digital Exits today. Although the sale prices of businesses are not always a guarantee of how good their strategies are, on average, they do give a fairly good indication of how good the market thinks they are.

In my opinion, the relatively low average price/earnings multiples suggest that whilst value can be created relatively quickly in ecommerce, the markets recognise that it can be very hard to hold on to.

Paul Garcia provides the following introductory text to the infographic which appears below:
Have you ever thought about how much your ecommerce business is worth? If you have, you aren't the only one. Everyone will eventually think about whether they should just sell the business for a massive payday or continue to grow it. When thinking about these things, it is important to get an accurate figure to ensure you can make the right decisions.

You can easily get the most accurate figure by simply using professionals, such as Digital Exits, to get a free valuation. They are also the people who created this helpful infographic. If you aren't ready to get a professional valuation, the using this tool will help to give you a better idea of where your business stands.

In this infographic, you will be seeing 150 different ecommerce businesses that were sold from 2010 to 2013. By using these statistics, you can easily measure your business and see exactly where it stands to figure out how much it is potentially worth. The statistics came from bizbuysell.com and the businesses were all U.S. based... although not all of the buyers were within the U.S. Of course, each sale is different, so you may be able to get less or even more than what this infographic says, but it is a great way to easily get an approximate value.

4 strategies for charging for things that used to be free

I recently asked (on Twitter) for examples of things that used to be free but for which people now charge.

The reasons for my interest are probably fairly obvious. Firstly, if you can find a way to charge for something that used to be free, you can effectively make money for nothing (in a manner of speaking). But secondly, and more relevantly to my inquiry, there has been a lot of talk about reversing the trend towards "free" that seems to have taken hold on the Internet, with the newspapers leading the charge, and I am curious to understand how this might work and whether it might succeed. Suffice to say, on a personal level I hope it fails as I am a voracious consumer of news and information on the Internet, but on a professional level I hope it succeeds because it could open up a lot of business opportunities.

The answers I received seem to fall into four categories:

1. Product / service enhancement

The first category represents things that used to be free but are now charged for because they have been altered or enhanced in some way.

For example, @TonySanchez1 suggested water.   I presume, of course, that he meant bottled water.  Do we pay for the water, do we pay to have it supplied in convenient bottles, or do we pay to have it purified or enriched with minerals and other trace elements?   I suspect that for most of us it is one of the latter two reasons.   After all, tap water itself remains as free, or nearly free, as it ever was.

2. Price disaggregation

The second category represents things that used to be included in the price for a primary service, but are now charged for separately.

For example, Tom Smith and @hiblen (both via Google Buzz) suggested that there were various things on air travel, including going to the toilet on Ryanair flights! which were once free but are now charged for.   The airlines suggest that these things are now charged for in order to keep the price of primary service, the flight itself, as low as possible.   So it is really a transfer of price from one part of the service to another, rather than a new charge altogether.

@wallsandfutures also suggested bad advice as an example.   I never got quite to he bottom of exactly what they had in mind and why they restricted their example to bad advice only, but this did call to mind the debate around the Financial Service Authority's Retail Distribution Review.   This proposes, amongst other things, that customers should pay an explicit fee for financial advice.   Currently, many advisers purport to offer customers free advice as they are paid by commission from the product providers.   However, of course, the cost of these commissions is simply built into the product fees that the customers pay to the product providers.   As I have pointed out in numerous forums, such fees are not a new charge against the customer, but rather a repackaging of the existing charges in such a way as to make them more explicit and controllable.

3. Pricing for communication

The third category is where a price is added in order to communicate a message rather than as a source of revenue.

For example, @JoeWi and @foxbeefly gave the example of plastic bags at supermarkets.   I suspect that plastic bags at supermarkets do not present much of a profitable business model.  After all, no one goes to the supermarket to buy bags, and once you're there you either need them or you don't.   But charging for plastic bags sends a very clear environmental message - "we care about the environment and we're doing something about it".   Even customers who are not impressed by the environmental sentiment are unlikely to complain.   So, charging for plastic bags is more about PR than it is a business model.

Tom Smith's example (again via Google Buzz rather than Twitter) of towels at the gym probably falls into the same category.

4. When loss leaders cease to lead

The fourth and final category represents cheap things that businesses used to deliberately give away in order to attract customers from which they make money from a completely different product or service.

@AndrewAppleyard suggested air at garages.  This is clearly something that used to be free (and still is in many places) as a value added service for customers coming into refuel their vehicles.   However, it is now often charged for without any changes to the product or the way it is delivered, with no discernible communicational value, and without any impact on the price of the primary service.   It's just something that some gas stations have decided to start charging for.   And it demonstrates one of the related problems - that of micro-payments.   As @AndrewAppleyard quickly pointed out, the 20p cost is often an irritant, or even a deterrent.

I suspect that garages don't make much money selling air.    But then again, if my understanding is correct, they don't make much money selling petrol either, and make most of their profit from selling conveniences in their forecourt stores.   I would guess that garages just realised that free air no longer made any contribution to attracting customer to the forecourt but also that charging customers would not drive them away (or cause them to drive themselves to the next petrol station).

However, the very first example I received in response to my initial inquiry was from @Hilary_MRM, who jumped straight in with content on News International sites.   That, of course, struck right at the heart of my enquiry.   Yes, we know that news providers, particularly Rupert Murdoch and the New York Times have made a lot of noise recently about charging for access to news online, but how much progress have they made in implementing this?   How many people actually sign up to pay compared to how many simply carry on reading the limited number of free articles you're allowed each month?   And if forced, will people pay, or will they simply switch to a competing news provider who has yet to implement charging?

The problem, as I see it, is that news publishers used to consider online news to be cheap, like air at petrol stations.   They were, after all, already producing it for their print publications, and could provide it online at relatively low cost.   They could also use it to draw customers into their sites, where, like forecourts made money out of them in their convenience stores, newspapers made money from them from online advertising.   However, with the collapse of both print news and online advertising, online news is not longer a cheap product, nor can it be justified in terms of the benefit of online advertising.   And customers don't need to drive somewhere to find a competing free offering as the next news sight is only a mouse-click away.

Finally, whilst petrol stations can rely on the fact that most of us can come up with a 20p to drop in the slot to get our tires pumped, the news publishers face the challenge that even if we were prepared to pay for online news content, there is no readily accessible and suitable system for micro-payments online.   The subscription model that Rupert Murdoch proposes seems unlikely to work as mos of use get our online information from a myriad of sources, and therefore could not satisfy all of our needs with a single subscription payment.   Rupert Murdoch could do worse, therefore, than to support innovative micro-payment models such as Flattr proposed by one of the founders of the Pirate Bay.

@Hilary_MRM's suggestion did give me pause to consider the problem from the other end.   How has the increasing availability of free information on the Internet impacted on those types of information that have never been free?   I am thinking here of specialist research publishers such as Gartner and Datamonitor.   Have their business models suffered as the quality of freely available information has increased, or have their markets proved resilient?

Beginning to charge for something your customers have become used to receiving for free can be done, but not easily.   I suspect that Rupert Murdoch will need a better strategy than simply mouthing off about the unfairness of a model in which was, until recently, happy to participate.   Like the music industry, I suspect that the news industry will have to reconsider both how it adds value (see, for example, The News Pyramid in the Social Media Age), and how it charges its customers.

This is an intensely interesting subject and a debate that is far from over.   I'd be very interested in hearing your opinions and examples in the comments below.

    Natural History - Inside Out

    Museums, like everyone else, must struggle to remain relevant in the face of rapidly changing consumer preferences. The new Darwin Centre at the Natural History Museum in London does an examplary job by turning the museum inside out. The new exhibit focuses, not on the animals, minerals and vegetables that are the focus of all of its other exhibits, but on the work that the scientists do behind the scenes. The centre contains exhibits describing the scientists' work, but more significantly, windows into working scientific laboratories where you can watch the scientists at work and even interact with them.

    I was there today with my parents and my three year old daughter. Imagine her delight when she spoke to the scientist behind the glass window and he answered her in an engaging and enthusiastic manner. Most of what he said would have been lost on her young mind (but not to the rest of the party), but I am sure that this real life and personal exhibit will have made a greater impression on her than all of the other interactive exhibits put together.

    As businesses struggle to adapt to an environment where customers are increasingly disinclined to be treated as faceless members of categorised target markets, they could do worse than to study the way in which the Natural History Museum has turned itself inside out and exposed its inner workings to the public.

    Oh, and thanks to all involved for a thoroughly informative and enjoyable day out.

    The difference between Viral Marketing and Viral Business Models

    It's every marketer's dream to "go viral".

    However, "viral" can mean two quite different things.

    Viral marketing
    The first meaning of "viral" is probably the most familiar as it has been around longer. Viral marketing refers to a marketing message which spreads within a community under their own volition (as opposed to one which must be broadcast by its sponsor).

    Wiktionary defines
    viral marketing
    as:
    A technique aiming at reproducing "word of mouth", usually on the internet or by e-mail, for humorous, political or marketing purposes.

    Some recent examples include:
    • Samsung's Extreme LED Sheep Art video: disconcertingly mesmerising, your guard will be down before the subtle product push appears right at the end.
    • CompareTheMarket.com's CompareTheMeerkat.com: so subtle that many people I've spoken to had not realised it was a CompareTheMarket.com add despite the CompareTheMarket.com name, logo and URL appearing at every conceivable opportunity.
    • The Large Hadron Rap: a brilliant effort to make something extremely complicated, buried underground and with the potential to destroy the entire universe both understandable and cool.
    The objectives of viral mareting are simple:
    • to increase awareness,
    • at a lower cost (certainly much lower than a conventional above-the-line advertising campaign),
    • to have some of the campaign attributes ("coolness", innovation, etc.) rub off on the brand (although P.T. Barnum supposedly suggested that "There's no such thing as bad publicity", a viral marketing campaign must surely aim for "good" publicity!), and
    • to get customers involved in spreading the message themselves, which subconsciously increases their comitment to the brand.
    Dan and Chip Heath have outlined their three secrets to make a message go viral. To summarise, these are:
    1. it's emotional,
    2. it feels like you're doing someone a favour by passing it on, and
    3. if contains a trigger to pass it on.
    Viral business models
    Whereas in viral marketing, it is only the marketing message that is viral, viral business models exhibit viral growth as an inherent part of the business model. That is, as a part of their normal interaction with the business, its customers publicise the business to others and/or invite them to become customers themselves.

    Examples of viral business models include:
    • Social Networking sites, such as Facebook, LinkedIn, and Twitter: There is no little to membership unless you friends or business contacts are also members, so each member is highly incentivised to encourage others to join. Further, once most of your friends or business contacts are members, you're undera lot of pressure to join up or risk being "left out".
    • Remote multi-player games and consoles: As with social networking sites, there is pressure to buy the same games and console that your friends have so that you can play along with them.
    • Peer Review sites, such as Amazon.com or Amazon.co.uk: These are similar to Social Networking sites, in that the more members there are (and are rating and reviewing the product), the more value each member gets. However, since you don't need to have any relationship to the other members, there is less incentive for you to sign them up - you simply gravitate to the site with the most existing and active members.
    • Multi-level marketing (MLM) or Network Marketing businesses: Not always popular and sometimes bordering on being pyramid and/or Ponzi schemes MLMs succeed by incentivising their members to recruitmore members.
    • Services that advertise themself when their customers use them to share their own content, such as free e-mail providers (gmail.com), blog hosts (blogger.com - visible at the top of this blog post), content sharing sites (youtube.com - used a few times in this post; and vimeo.com - also used in this post) all of which advertise themselves in their URLs if not more overtly.
    In his review of Product Planner, Jason Kincaid suggests that the key to creating a viral business model is to create a circular process where by each activity in the cycle involves promoting to or inviting additional users. This process can be the member enrolment process itself, but its even better another process, such as the video embed loop at Vimeo, as the customer will have multiple opportunities to publicise the business and/or invite new members as their familiarity with and confidence in it increases (people are more likely to want to recomment something with which they are familiar than something which is still new to them).

    Viral busines models tend have "tipping points" - points at which the adoption rates change markedly. These can be hard to predict. For example, in we were so wrong about Twitter, Rob Diana, suggests that one of the tipping points for Twitter was the adoption by celebrities such as Ashton Kutcher, Britney Spears and Oprah.

    The difference between these two meanings of "viral" is significant in its application to businesses. Any business can create a viral marketing campaign. All you need is a sufficiently talented creative team (how about the viral factory and their wikipedia page), and, perhaps, a bit of luck. (That is not to imply that it is easy!) However, a viral business model needs to be built into a new business from the outset, or will require significant business re-engineering to implement into an existing business. I'd hesitate to say anything is impossible, but some existing businesses simply won't lend themselves to viral busines models.

    Related articles